Is a single alphabet letter registrable as a trademark?
14 October 2026
Is a single alphabet letter registrable as a trademark in the Philippines? Yes, according to the Supreme Court of the Philippines, in its decision involving three consolidated opposition and cancellation actions filed by Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, a U.S.-based company against Oceanic Empire Limited, a British Virgin Islands company. The actions were docketed as G.R. Nos. 262551, 266971 & 275314, promulgated on January 28, 2026, and uploaded to the Supreme Court portal on May 7, 2026.
Background. On June 19, 2015, Oceanic filed three trademark applications for its real estate projects in the Philippines, namely: W TOWER, W GLOBAL CENTER and W FIFTH AVENUE, in Class 36 covering the services “real estate affairs.” Starwood opposed the applications for W GLOBAL CENTER and W FIFTH AVENUE, and petitioned the cancellation of the mark W TOWER, which had matured to registration on November 19, 2015, on the ground that the dominant element of said marks was the bold letter “W” which was confusingly similar to its popular trademark “W”, registered with the Intellectual Property Office of the Philippines (IPOPHL) since 2007 and 2008, and covered closely related services in Classes 37, 41, 43 and 44, and further contended that Oceanic’s marks intended to ride on the popularity or goodwill of its “W” mark, resulting in the confusion and deception of the purchasing public.
In its defense, Oceanic claimed that (i) nobody could monopolize the letter “W,” (ii) the additional words “GLOBAL CENTER,” “FIFTH AVENUE” and “TOWER” sufficiently distinguished the marks and (iii) that its business focussed on real estate while Starwood operated hotels and resorts.
The dispute yielded conflicting rulings as it moved through administrative and judicial channels.
Decision of the adjudication officer of the Bureau of Legal Affairs of the IPOPHL.The adjudication officer dismissed Starwood’s oppositions, as well as its petition for cancellation, ruling that there was no confusing similarity between the competing parties’ marks. In all three cases, the adjudication officer held that Starwood cannot have a monopoly on the use of the letter “W” to the exclusion of others, that the descriptive terms added by Oceanic (i.e. “TOWER”, “GLOBAL CENTER” and “FIFTH AVENUE”) sufficiently distinguished the marks, and that real estate buyers are sophisticated consumers unlikely to be misled.
Decision of the director of the Bureau of Legal Affairs of the IPOPHL. Not satisfied with the ruling of the adjudication officer, Starwood appealed to the BLA director, who reversed and set aside the adjudication officer’s rulings in favour of Starwood, holding that confusion will likely occur between the two marks where it is evident that the distinguishing element of both parties’ marks is the immediately apparent, stylized “W”, depicted in bold font. The director also ruled that the addition of other terms such as “TOWER”, “FIFTH AVENUE” or “GLOBAL CENTER” were insufficient to distinguish Oceanic’s marks as these terms were merely descriptive, and also noted that “GLOBAL CENTER” and “FIFTH AVENUE” were expressly disclaimed in their trademark applications. Moreover, the Director also found that although the marks belonged to different classes, Oceanic’s real estate affairs were closely related to and were broad enough to encompass Starwood’s hotel and motel services, and building construction and installation services.
Decisions of the IPOPHL director general and separate divisions of the Court of Appeals ultimately reinstated the findings in favour for Oceanic. Across all three cases, the court found no confusing similarity, ruling that Starwood's single-letter mark lacked inherent distinctiveness and that Oceanic’s composite marks displayed clear visual and typographical differences. The court stressed that because the marks fell under different Nice classifications, no legal presumption of likelihood of confusion arose. Given the high-value nature of the services, the court concluded that discerning consumers were unlikely to be misled, while also finding no evidence of bad faith on the part of Oceanic.
Following the denial of its motions for reconsideration, Starwood elevated separate appeals for all three cases to the Supreme Court.
Decision of the Supreme Court.Reversing the Court of Appeals, the Supreme Court granted Starwood’s petitions.Addressing Starwood's standalone word mark “W”, the court agreed with the lower tribunals that a standard character mark consisting solely of a single plain letter lacks distinctiveness and cannot grant exclusive rights over that letter. However, the Supreme Court underscored Starwood’s clarification that it does not lay claim over any and all configurations of the letter “W”; rather, it defends its ownership over a unique and particular stylized , which is in bold typeface, in sans-serif font style, in uppercase letters, with slightly-wide arms or slightly-apart stems, in solid, straight and sharp design. Applying the dominancy test, the Supreme Court held that this stylized letter is the dominant or prevalent feature of both Starwood’s and Oceanic’s marks.
The Supreme Court deduced that to the average consumer, the stylized of both marks resemble each other, in that they have a sans-serif font and are depicted in boldface and uppercase with slightly wide arms in solid design.
First, emphasis has been clearly and deliberately placed on the stylized W by printing it in bold typeface, thus isolating them from the additional terms by qualifying them, similar to Starwood’s mark. Regardless of whether located beside or below the , the additional terms “TOWER”, “GLOBAL CENTER” and “FIFTH AVENUE” appear subordinated to the stylized W in thickness, arrangement, and overall visual impact.
Second, the words “TOWER” and “HOTELS” are merely generic, while the terms “GLOBAL CENTER” and “FIFTH AVENUE”, absent proof of acquisition of secondary meaning, may also be considered as descriptive marks, referring merely to the geographical location of the building and the intended commercial purpose the mark pertains to.
Third, that it is this stylized that catches the immediate attention is further strengthened by the analogous way the subject marks have actually been used in commerce, i.e., through the prominent display of the marks in their respective buildings. Rule 18, Section 5 of the Revised IP Rules reminds us that in determining likelihood of confusion, consideration must be given based on the visual comparisons and overall impressions of the marks as they are encountered in the realities of the marketplace. In actual commercial trade, both parties prominently displayed the stylized
on the facades of their physical buildings. Oceanic’s mark, as actually used and advertised, either only exhibits the stylized W on the façade, or has such additional terms “TOWER”, “GLOBAL CENTER”, and “FIFTH AVENUE” below the stylized
.
This finding reaffirms the principle established in Skechers, U.S.A., Inc. v. Inter Pacific Industrial Trading Corp.(662 Phil. 11 [2011]), where the Supreme Court applied the dominancy test to protect a stylized single-letter mark. In said case, the court held that while petitioner’s stylized “S” is within an oval design, said stylized “S” is the mark’s dominant feature, as it is what catches the eye of the purchaser; and that the fact that respondent used the same stylized “S” already constitutes infringement under the dominancy test. In finding similarity between the parties’ marks, the Supreme Court noted that rather than merely using the letter “S,” the respondent adopted the very same font, size and unique stylized “S” that distinguishes the petitioner’s registered trademark.
Addressing the relatedness of the parties’ services, the court rejected reliance on Nice Classifications, referencing the landmark doctrine in Kolin Electronics Co., Inc. v. Kolin, wherein the Supreme Court abandoned the use of product or service classification as a factor in determining relatedness. According to the Supreme Court, the subject marks involve related services in that: (1) notwithstanding perceived distinctions as to duration of use, i.e. long-term lease for residential or commercial purposes for Oceanic vis-à-vis shorter-term hotels stays for Starwood, both marks nonetheless cover services that involve the use and occupation of spaces; and (2) the brand value and prestige of both their businesses heavily rely on the consuming public’s recognition, assessment and appreciation of their respective buildings, especially their locations and aesthetic quality.
Lastly, the Supreme Court held that it is of no moment that Starwood does not currently have a physical hotel operating in the Philippines, reaffirming its decision in W Land Holdings Inc. v. Starwood [822 Phil. 23 (2017)], wherein it acknowledged the actual use of a trademark within this jurisdiction, where it was established that the registered mark was able to produce discernible commercial activity within the Philippines, or at the very least, create commercial interaction with local consumers who are able to avail and book amenities and other services in any of its hotels worldwide through its interactive website. Notwithstanding Starwood’s lack of a physical hotel in the Philippines, it is likely that patrons familiar with Starwood’s line of international hotels confuse Oceanic’s high-end commercial spaces as being associated with the former’s brand. Jurisprudence has likewise recognized that every registered trademark owner enjoys protection in product and market areas that are the normal expansion of its business.
The Supreme Court noted that it is also not uncommon for hotel brands to branch out and extend their luxurious or aesthetic branding to residential commercial or other spaces to broaden their reputation in property management. Thus, it is entirely possible that even ordinarily intelligent and sophisticated buyers of real property will perceive Oceanic’s services as being connected with Starwood’s brand.
Ultimately, the Starwood decision underscores that junior applicants cannot circumvent trademark law simply by appending generic or descriptive terms to an established brand’s dominant graphic mark. By affirming that distinctive typography transforms a common alphabet character into a protectable mark, and by focusing on confusion of business rather than mere product confusion, the Supreme Court highlighted the dual purpose of trademark law: to shield the public from mistaken affiliation in overlapping commercial spheres, while guarding the proprietary goodwill and reputation that a trademark owner has built across related industries.